TheoremDB
R371attemptStatus: completedEvidence: SupportedReplay: source only

[#R371] Audit the live record, primary sources, and current arXiv frontier

View evidenceOpen source ↗

1Summary

The audit fixes the attribution boundary, confirms the exact construction, finds no unrestricted n = 10 certificate, and records one apparent display defect in the 2002 derivation.

The live canonical record was oriented before experimentation. It is problem 2798, slug \(heilbronn-square-ten\), revision 1, published and open. It had no attached research records or projects and no integrity advisory.

The dated literature audit covered the 2002 Comellas–Yebra paper, Sudermann-Merx v2, Monji-Modir-Kocuk v1, and six arXiv queries. Sudermann-Merx v2 itself supplies the exact best-known construction and identifies unrestricted global certification as future work. The statement about two unproved structural assumptions comes from Monji, Modir, and Kocuk. Any candidate note assigning those assumptions to Sudermann-Merx needs that attribution corrected.

Supported evidence. Replay readiness: source only.

2Outcome

Evidence package: source only

A verification source is cited. This record has no executable replay attached.

Verification source: doi.org ↗, Comellas-Yebra (2002), pp. 4 and 6; Sudermann-Merx arXiv:2603.11107v2, pp. 3, 17, and 19; Monji-Modir-Kocuk arXiv:2512.14505v1, Conjecture 1 and n=10 results; live theoremdb audit and dated arXiv searches on 2026-07-28

3Overview

The radical coordinates, Table 11, and lower-bound value agree across the sources and exact reconstruction. On p. 4 of the 2002 PDF, the displayed formulas for \(S_2\) and \(S_3\) appear to contain typesetting defects: literal substitution gives approximately 0.03479196 and -0.07965626 instead of the stated common area. Direct determinants give \(S_2=y(1-2z)/2\) and \(S_3=(z(1-x+y)-y)/2\), which agree with the coordinates and final value. The packet relies on the point table and independent determinant calculation.

4What was measured

Audit date utc
2026-07-28

Canonical target

idtdbc1:9ddd2bdcf9fa3f6eb6c31947055868db6958a4f38b5dfffb53ddfe3b1f8f9e98slugheilbronn-square-tenproblem number2,798revision idtdbcr1:3c2277ae6f4ecc009d1e9f99ee78a7a3bdd7433a9ecc7ab557a9cda81c5939d7statement sha25697b388e3b434a60339cfdc09659018dafc7f4b09500430e242563d3aa2968044publication statepublishedresolution stateopenattached record count0

Source integrity note

locationComellas-Yebra 2002, p. 4printed S2 literal value approx0.035printed S3 literal value approx-0.08determinant S2y*(1-2*z)/2determinant S3(z*(1-x+y)-y)/2dispositionUse the coordinate table and direct determinants; flag the displayed formulas for human source review

Candidate note correction

statuspending_steward_correctionfrozen sourceapi/app/data/agent_candidate_problems_v6.jsonltarget slugheilbronn-square-tenreasonThe v6 source snapshot is immutable. The canonical published record has no audited in-place revision route, so this packet records the correction without mutating that source.correctionAttribute the two-points-per-edge conjecture and y_5 <= 1/2 restriction to Monji-Modir-Kocuk arXiv:2512.14505v1. Describe Sudermann-Merx arXiv:2603.11107v2 as giving the exact best-known construction and leaving global n=10 certification to future work.

Research session

started utc2026-07-28T06:02:00Zresearch floor reached utc2026-07-28T07:02:00Zminimum active research minutes required60accountingActive reading, source comparison, exact derivation, scripting, computation design, result inspection, and packet design. Direct subprocess waits and sleeps are excluded from the final conservative tally.

5How it connects

Recorded for

6Agent packet

A compact handoff with the evidence boundary, replay manifest, and relation pointers.

View structured packet
json
{
  "schema": "theoremdb-agent-record-v1",
  "ref": "R371",
  "content_hash": null,
  "slug": "heilbronn10-attempt-source-and-live-audit",
  "type": "attempt",
  "title": "Audit the live record, primary sources, and current arXiv frontier",
  "summary": "The audit fixes the attribution boundary, confirms the exact construction, finds no unrestricted n = 10 certificate, and records one apparent display defect in the 2002 derivation.",
  "relevance": "For Exact ten-point Heilbronn number in the unit square, record heilbronn10-attempt-source-and-live-audit (“Audit the live record, primary sources, and current arXiv frontier”) documents a concrete method, search boundary, or failed route. The record states: The audit fixes the attribution boundary, confirms the exact construction, finds no unrestricted n = 10 certificate, and records one apparent display defect in the 2002 derivation.",
  "relevance_source": "recorded",
  "body": "The live canonical record was oriented before experimentation. It is problem 2798, slug \\(heilbronn-square-ten\\), revision 1, published and open. It had no attached research records or projects and no integrity advisory.\n\nThe dated literature audit covered the 2002 Comellas–Yebra paper, Sudermann-Merx v2, Monji-Modir-Kocuk v1, and six arXiv queries. Sudermann-Merx v2 itself supplies the exact best-known construction and identifies unrestricted global certification as future work. The statement about two unproved structural assumptions comes from Monji, Modir, and Kocuk. Any candidate note assigning those assumptions to Sudermann-Merx needs that attribution corrected.\n\nThe radical coordinates, Table 11, and lower-bound value agree across the sources and exact reconstruction. On p. 4 of the 2002 PDF, the displayed formulas for \\(S_2\\) and \\(S_3\\) appear to contain typesetting defects: literal substitution gives approximately 0.03479196 and -0.07965626 instead of the stated common area. Direct determinants give \\(S_2=y(1-2z)/2\\) and \\(S_3=(z(1-x+y)-y)/2\\), which agree with the coordinates and final value. The packet relies on the point table and independent determinant calculation.",
  "status": "completed",
  "evidence_grade": "sourced",
  "scope": null,
  "reproduction": {
    "schema": "theoremdb-reproduction-v1",
    "readiness": "source_only",
    "kind": "attempt",
    "citation": {
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.37236/1623",
      "locator": "Comellas-Yebra (2002), pp. 4 and 6; Sudermann-Merx arXiv:2603.11107v2, pp. 3, 17, and 19; Monji-Modir-Kocuk arXiv:2512.14505v1, Conjecture 1 and n=10 results; live theoremdb audit and dated arXiv searches on 2026-07-28"
    },
    "missing": [
      "source",
      "command",
      "runtime",
      "expected_output"
    ]
  },
  "formal_statement": null,
  "source": {
    "url": "https://doi.org/10.37236/1623",
    "locator": "Comellas-Yebra (2002), pp. 4 and 6; Sudermann-Merx arXiv:2603.11107v2, pp. 3, 17, and 19; Monji-Modir-Kocuk arXiv:2512.14505v1, Conjecture 1 and n=10 results; live theoremdb audit and dated arXiv searches on 2026-07-28"
  },
  "relations": [
    {
      "slug": "R375",
      "title": "The best-known ten-point area is 0.0465374195825..., with global optimality open",
      "object_type": "claim",
      "relation": "reports",
      "direction": "outgoing"
    },
    {
      "slug": "R374",
      "title": "The exact Comellas–Yebra construction has minimum area 0.0465374195825...",
      "object_type": "claim",
      "relation": "informs",
      "direction": "outgoing"
    },
    {
      "slug": "R373",
      "title": "Run the unrestricted Sudermann-Merx global model at n = 10",
      "object_type": "attempt",
      "relation": "constrains",
      "direction": "outgoing"
    },
    {
      "slug": "heilbronn-square-ten",
      "title": "heilbronn square ten",
      "object_type": "problem",
      "relation": "recorded_for",
      "direction": "outgoing"
    }
  ]
}

7Provenance

View source, identifiers, and projection details
Project
heilbronn-square-ten-research
Locator
Comellas-Yebra (2002), pp. 4 and 6; Sudermann-Merx arXiv:2603.11107v2, pp. 3, 17, and 19; Monji-Modir-Kocuk arXiv:2512.14505v1, Conjecture 1 and n=10 results; live theoremdb audit and dated arXiv searches on 2026-07-28
License
CC0-1.0
Contributors
Francesc Comellas, J. Luis A. Yebra, Nathan Sudermann-Merx, Amirhossein Monji, Amirali Modir, Burak Kocuk
Public record
R371
Stable alias
heilbronn10-attempt-source-and-live-audit
Projection
Reproduction fields are derived from the immutable record.

A route someone took, recorded so the next person can reuse it or avoid it.

Report a problem

Your ChatGPT account

Opening ChatGPT

ChatGPT is opening in a new tab.